Closing Blog Was ‘Painful’

2009-09-16

A noted Vietnamese blogger and government critic describes her detention.

AFP Photo

Vietnamese online at an Internet cafe in Hanoi, Aug. 22, 2007.

BANGKOK—A well-known Vietnamese blogger said it was “painful” to quit her online writing, which had been critical of the government, but she agreed to stop so she could be released from detention.

Nguyen Ngoc Nhu Quynh, 31, who blogged as “Me Nam,” or “Mushroom's Mother,” was arrested Sept. 3. She was the last of three bloggers recently arrested and released for what the government says were legitimate national security reasons.

“They told me not to use that blog. They said that was a political plot by some Vietnamese… that that was what incited me,” she said. “I accepted everything so I could go home.”

“Stopping a blog is simple—you just close it,” she said. “But today when I had to announce that I won’t blog anymore, it was painful.”

Being in prison for “10 days and nine nights—it was terrible,” she said in an interview.

In her last blog posting, Nguyen Ngoc Nhu Quynh wrote a farewell letter to her readers.

In the entry, she explains that the hardship she endured in prison caused her to give up writing.

"Through what happened to me in the last few days, I painfully recognize that how we express patriotism still depends on the regime," she said.

"Participants…must abide by the rules of the game, and in my current position, I don’t have a choice."

Mining at issue

On 27 August, blogger Bui Thanh Hieu, also known as Nguoi Buon Gio, was arrested in Hanoi.

A day later journalist Pham Doan Trang, who worked for one of the most visited semi-official news Web sites, VietnamNet, was also arrested. She also ran a well-read personal blog.

All three opposed China's claims of sovereignty over the Spratly and Paracel islands in the South China Sea, which Vietnam, among other governments, also claims.

They also criticized a government plan to partner with a Chinese state-owned firm to exploit bauxite reserves in Vietnam's Central Highlands.

Bauxite mining drew national attention last year when war hero Gen. Vo Nguyen Giap urged the government to reconsider it. Hanoi doesn’t want anti-China sentiments to get out of hand, and it tightly controls the country’s media.

Officials said “their plan to exploit bauxite is in the interest of the whole country, not of some individual group,” Nguyen Ngoc Nhu Quynh said. “But I’m upset because this information isn’t open to the public.

She said she was questioned several times in July this year when she wore a T-shirt opposing the bauxite mine and asserting that the Spratly and Paracel islands belong to Vietnam.

Pledge to be ‘more subtle’

Bui Thanh Hieu, 37, the blogger also known as Nguoi Buon Gio or “Wind Trader,” was released Sept. 5.

He was arrested in late August after blogging critically about the planned bauxite mine and Vietnam’s disputed claim to islands in the South China Sea.

“I will continue reading blogs. I might continue writing, but I will write in a more subtle way. I will write in a way that is more suitable for my situation,” he said in an interview.

Police searched Hieu's house after his arrest and confiscated two of his computers and other personal belongings, the Free Journalists Network of Vietnam (FJNV), an independent press freedom group, said.

Pham Doan Trang, 31, was released Sept. 6 after being arrested in late August. Her blog, titled “Ridiculous,” covered the same topics.

Hanoi’s new watchdog

On Sept. 3, the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) condemned the arrests and said in a statement that Trang had recently reported on territorial disputes with China.

It cited the FJNV as saying Trang also shared sensitive information with bloggers and other journalists about a Chinese advisor for economic and trade issues who called on his Vietnamese counterparts to discipline certain local newspapers and journalists.

The Vietnamese government created the Administration Agency for Radio, Television, and Electronics Information in 2008 and charged it with with monitoring the Internet and bloggers.

In recent months, authorities have blocked local access to Singapore-based Yahoo 360°, according to CPJ. The site was nearly exclusively popular with Vietnamese bloggers.

Yahoo recently introduced a new version of its service called Yahoo 360+, but many bloggers do not trust the site's privacy provisions and have moved to WordPress or social networking sites such as Facebook and Multiply.

Original reporting by An Nguyen for RFA's Vietnamese service. Vietnamese service director: Diem Nguyen. Translated by Hanh Seide. Written for Web in English by Sarah Jackson-Han.

Story Tools

E-mail this story
Subscribe to email newsletter
Print...
Share this story

Blogger Says Goodbye


Dear Friends:

The time has come for me to put an end to this blog. I came to this blog as an adventure, to explore the world of information. And every joy ride has to come to an end. Participants…must abide by the rules of the game, and in my current position, I don’t have a choice. It is because I have made a promise, and I will respect my decision and promise.

Perhaps I have disappointed many friends with these words.

But I know and understand myself more than anyone. I don’t dare to call myself a heroine or proud descendant of the bloodline of heroes. And because of that, after 10 days and nine nights in prison, I declared my decision to give up.

I was wrong, and I have to take responsibilities for my actions. Had I been in a different position, and I, still as a patriotic Vietnamese, just said to myself looking in the mirror in the morning, “No bauxite, no China—the Spratly and Paracel islands belong to Vietnam,” things would be different today.

Through what happened to me in the last few days, I painfully recognize that how we express patriotism still depends on the regime.

Dear Friends:

I am actually very touched, and I deeply cherish all the care and concern you have sent to me and my family in the last few days. In this last [blog] entry, I’d like to use my own handwriting to say goodbye.

Deep in my heart, I truly believe that we will eventually meet again somewhere on this cyber super-highway, for we all share the same belief in our own spirits and Vietnamese determination.

I send wishes for health, peace, and happiness to all the friends on my list and also to friends from the blog whom I have had the honor of knowing.

Written in Nha Trang province on this 13th day of September 2009.
Nguyen Ngoc Nhu Quynh


Radio Free Asia
2025 M Street NW, Suite 300
Washington DC 20036, USA
202-530-4900
contact@rfa.org