US Striving to Solve Rohingya Issue

But rights groups say Burma's government is not moving fast enough to help.
2012-10-10
Email story
Comment on this story
Share story
Print story
  • Print
  • Share
  • Comment
  • Email
Muslim women hold their children at their house in Sittwe, June 6, 2012.
Muslim women hold their children at their house in Sittwe, June 6, 2012.
AFP

The United States is working with the international community to find a resolution to the troublesome Rohingya issue, including possible citizenship for members of the Muslim minority group in Burma, officials say.

But rights groups do not see significant moves under way by the Burmese government to fully address the problem, even in efforts to pave the way for the return home of thousands of Rohingyas displaced by deadly violence in northwestern Rakhine state in June.

State Department refugee expert Kelly Clements said that recent talks between the U.S. and Burma have “explored how the international community can assist the Burmese government in long-term recovery efforts” following the violence, in which more than 80 died and 75,000 were displaced, mostly Rohingyas.

Additionally, an end to the Rohingyas’ stateless status must be found for those members of the group who can make valid claims to citizenship, Clements said on Tuesday at a forum held by the Open Society Foundation in Washington.

“We explored how the international community can assist the Burmese government in long-term recovery efforts and the development of a path to citizenship for those Rohingya with claims.”

“Peace is possible in Rakhine State only through economic development, poverty alleviation and ensuring basic rights for residents,” Clements said.

sittwe-map-305.jpg

Stateless

The Rohingya are not recognized as an ethnic group in Burma even though many members of the group have lived in the country for decades. They have been classified by the U.N. as one of the world’s most persecuted minorities.

Clements said citizenship is often the gateway to a person’s ability to realize a range of human rights and basic services, including freedom of movement, freedom from discrimination and arbitrary arrest and detention, the right to vote, access to education, and property ownership.

“Citizenship is a core concept that defines the relationship between a state and an individual—each has obligations to the other.”

The Rohingya, a people whose ethnic identity and origin are highly disputed, were rendered stateless in Burma by the passage of the 1982 Myanmar Citizenship Law.

Clements said that some historical accounts note that Rohingyas have been indigenous to Rakhine since the 9th century.

Rakhine was at one time the kingdom of Arakan, which also occupied southern parts of modern Bangladesh. Burma's 800,000 Rohingya speak a dialect similar to one spoken in Bangladesh, where some 300,000 Rohingya also live.

Other accounts claim that the Rohingya migrated to the region during the British colonial period, Clements said.

“This latter claim has consistently fueled anti-Rohingya sentiment, leading to periodic tension and violence against the Rohingya by the former military regime after Burma gained independence.”

Clements said that peace in Rakhine state, where more than 80 died in the June violence by official count, and where about 75,000 from both the Rohingya and the Rakhine Buddhist communities remain displaced, will be restored only through economic development, poverty alleviation, and guarantees of basic rights for residents.

The U.S., she said, is working closely with the international community and countries affected by Rohingya displacement to reach a “comprehensive, sustainable, and just solution to their plight.”

“Our commitment to resolving this intractable problem is clear,” Clements said.

'Nothing on track'

Despite talks between the United States and Burma, though, rights groups do not expect any resolution to the issue soon.

While discussions on bringing peace to Rakhine have taken place, “nothing that needs to happen is on track to happen,” said Human Rights Watch Asia advocacy director John Sifton, also speaking at the Open Society Foundations.

“The current situation is intolerable,” Sifton said.

“Huge amounts of political pressure need to be placed on the Burmese government to make things happen, and that’s pressure that the United States government and the EU [European Union] will have to bring to bear.”

Following the June violence in Rakhine, Burma’s national government seemed to have no plan to return people to their homes, Sifton said.

“Unfortunately, [this] still seems to be the case.”

The United States and other concerned countries should ask the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights to set up an office in Burma to serve as a “neutral arbiter of facts and recommendations,” Sifton said.

Though Burma now receives regular visits from U.N. Special Rapporteur for Human Rights Tomas Quintana, an established office could fully monitor the post-violence situation in Rakhine, the release of Burmese political prisoners, and cease-fires negotiated with Burma’s other ethnic groups, Sifton said.

“So from the beginning, we’ve been raising this as a thing that needs to be done and could have a huge impact for all of Burma.”

Reported by Richard Finney.

Comments (6)
  • Print
  • Share
  • Email

KoKo

from Mandalay

We do not need OIC in our land. Get out OIC. OIC must not come to Myanmar. We do want OIC. We do not need OIC. Because Muslims is very bad. We know Muslims are terrorists and murders. So We do not need OIC.For example Bangali(so-called Rohingya) Muslims are very bad. They are real terrorists and murders. They are real joining many terrorist of organizations of all over the world.

Oct 16, 2012 02:38 AM

A human being

Refusing them citizenship is disgusting! It should not be about religion or ethnicity. U.s is clearly not interested and has done nothing to save the lives of innocent children. The world is ignoring the genocide of innocent human beings and when burmeese budhist try to defend their actions and government( myanmar) actions it makes me nauseated.

Oct 13, 2012 05:49 PM

Anonymous Reader

Rohingyas will become serious suicide bombers one day when Burmese government stupidily allows them citizenship rights. It's 100% for sure, Allah!

Oct 12, 2012 09:56 AM

Anonymously Rohingyas

Anonymous Reader; Yours prediction is wrong the Rohingyas will become the serious atomic suicide bombers indeed. If the Burmese government allows their citizenship rights then the government is stupid, if the government expelled them to a third nation then the government is very good. Ok the government to do what you want to do but you will prepare the land or the nation first before repatriates or expels to them. In another comment of you suggested to right groups to teach them (Bengali) what is the human ethic and what is the civilization need for humankind. You think first of your comment how mercilessly blamed to others and advising to the right groups then you could get the right answer. Think 100 times before to say anything to others that is the humankind and better civilization.

Oct 12, 2012 08:01 PM

Matt

from Chicago

It's true that Arakan Kings used to rule southern Bangladesh intermittently from 13th century and 14th century until 1666. Islam came to current northern Bangladesh only around 14 century and the number of people who practice are quite low. There are many tribes like Chakma and Hindu living in the southern Bangladesh. After Partition, new country Pakistan was formed and religious riots between Muslims and non-Muslims occurred. All Hindus from East Pakistan (current Bangladesh) moved back to West Bengal state of India in fear for their lives.

Whenever talked about this so called Rohingya issue, don't just think about current Muslim state of Bangladesh. Think also what British has done and also recent history.

Oct 12, 2012 09:10 AM

Azmi

from Germany

I think the misconception and misbehavior should be corrected bcz Rohingyas are not Bengali by any means.Peace and harmony can be achieved by giving full ethnic and citizenship right otherwise it will be deadlock the peace in that region.Misusing and abusing of propaganda can't bring peace by any other ethnics in the future.

Oct 11, 2012 01:11 PM

View all comments.

CH. 1: MANDARIN | CANTONESE

CH. 2: VIETNAMESE | BURMESE | KOREAN

CH. 3: KHMER | LAO | UYGHUR

CH. 4: TIBETAN

More Listening Options

View Full Site