Lao Delegation Ducks Questions at UN Rights Review

Email story
Comment on this story
Print story
Lao delegate Phoukhong Sisoulath addresses the UN Human Rights Committee in Geneva, July 11, 2018.
Lao delegate Phoukhong Sisoulath addresses the UN Human Rights Committee in Geneva, July 11, 2018.
Screen grab from UN Web TV

Lao government representatives evaded tough questioning at a U.N. review of the country’s rights record last week, speaking to points that had not been raised and saying that villagers arrested for refusing to leave confiscated land had sought to block the country’s development.

Meeting in Geneva, Switzerland, from July 11 to 12, the U.N. Human Rights Committee (CCPR) examined for the first time the state of civil and political rights in communist Laos. The committee tracks the compliance of state signatories to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

Laos became a state party to the Covenant in 2009.

Addressing the disappearance of Sombath Somphone, an agricultural expert who vanished at a police checkpoint outside the Lao capital Vientiane in 2012, Lao delegate Bounkeut Sangsomsak refused to answer detailed questions from the Committee concerning government efforts to find the missing civil society leader.

Instead, the minister to the Lao prime minister’s office and delegation head spoke of Sombath, who had challenged government land deals that had left Lao villagers homeless, as a personal friend whose “personality had changed” after his return to Laos following studies in the United States.

Sombath also had previously unreported assets, including parcels of land and property in the capital amounting to from 1 to 2 million U.S. dollars, Bounkeut claimed, citing information he said he had “only recently” been made aware of.

“Where did all this money come from?” Bounkeut asked.

'So-called wife'

In an apparent attack on Sombath’s wife Ng Shui Meng, who has embarrassed the Lao government by campaigning tirelessly for answers to her husband’s disappearance, Bounkeut referred to Ng as Sombath’s  “so-called wife,” saying no legal documents have been found to confirm their marriage.

Responding to questions concerning the arrest and beating in 2017 of Lao villagers in Sekong province, including children, for “obstructing workers” and cutting down trees on village land granted by the Lao government to a Vietnamese rubber company, Lao delegate Phoukhong Sisoulath called the group “only a few people” who had refused compensation.

“About 100 other families agreed to receive new land, and only a few people refused,” he said.

“So I think this is not about defending the land. It’s about the ill intentions of a very small group to obstruct the development of the country,” he said.

Speaking to RFA’s Lao Service in an interview, Phil Robertson, deputy Asia director for the rights group Human Rights Watch, said that in both cases raised by the Committee, Laos had tried to “change the conversation.”

Especially in the case of Sombath Somphone, “They’re trying to do anything they can to move away from the issue of accountability for what has happened to Sombath, from answering the hard questions like ‘Where is he? Has he been killed? Where is his body?’”

“All of these things are answers that they don’t want to give, and so they’re going to try to use any sort of tactic they can to try to change the subject of the discussion.”

'Shocking, callous'

Also speaking to RFA, a foreign researcher who has worked in Laos for 10 years called the delegation’s comments regarding Sombath “inappropriate and shockingly callous.”

“They are clearly a tactic to divert attention away from the lack of progress in the investigation and lack of accountability on the part of the government, and to present Sombath’s abduction as a business-related crime rather than an enforced disappearance,” the researcher said, speaking on condition of anonymity.

And the delegation’s comments about the detained villagers, one of whom died in custody under mysterious circumstances, were notable for what they did not reveal about the case, the researcher said.

“What kind of compensation was offered to the affected families?” he asked. “What kind of land were they given in compensation? And how were the other families ‘convinced’ to accept that compensation?” he asked.

“Equally important, what is the justification for the jailing and mistreatment of the villagers who rejected the compensation?”

“Coercion cannot be presented as consent,” he said.

Reported and translated by Ounkeo Souksavanh for RFA’s Lao Service. Written in English by Richard Finney.

Comments (6)


from Chicago Jack

This so call free world USA has put more people in jail than any other country in the world. Why? you asked, because USA is legally corrupted and jail are run by private companies. The more people they can put in jail the more money they make. Each person that they lock up cause tax payer over $20000 each a year. Police brutality in the US in out of control, again over 1000 people killed by police each year that is too much. Can they just shoot people in the leg or arm instead of to kill.

Aug 04, 2018 03:28 PM

Anonymous Reader

Still the US is better than Vietnam. Don't speak too loud boy. When China is coming to your door step who are you going to turn to? Luckily they've already sent you some assistance. Stop comparing a free world country to a communist country because you convince no-one except the 5 retarded countries such as China, Vietnam, Laos, North and Cuba.Soon there's no more of them.

Aug 06, 2018 05:09 PM

Anonymous Reader

Dear dog-eater, let's put it this way. The free world is not perfect but it's better than a commie regime. I think you live in the US, so please go back to commie land where you belong. Judging by your name, I think you might be a Vietnamese commie unless you're from Laos where your kins are exploiting the country with the help from the blooding-sucking government. So back there and don't come out to live in the free world. Commies who live in the free world are not human beings they are animals like their peers in their own countries.

Aug 07, 2018 02:51 AM

Anonymous Reader

Lao commies wouldn't care less for their own people. The collapse of the dam in southern Laos can attest how far these animals can go. As long as they can pocket huge commissions Lao people can die five times over this cannot make them change their minds.

Jul 29, 2018 06:35 PM

Anonymous Reader

Why Mr Sisoulath looks so stupid when speaks? Maybe it's because he knows that he's lying.

Jul 29, 2018 05:44 AM


from Chicago Jack

USA so call good country why the hell police killed over 1000 people each year. Isn't this a human right too.

Jul 24, 2018 12:15 AM

Anonymous Reader

You can go back to Vietnam or Laos if that's you care for.Please don't come out to live in the free world countries.

Aug 01, 2018 01:54 AM

Anonymous Reader

This is the techniques learnt from their commie masters of east Europe. When being asked about issues that embarras them they avoid to answer entirely. It's like someone asked about the weather in southern Laos they would say they had a good time dancing with Chinese delegates the night before.I still don't understand why the free world cares so much about this land of no law. Cut all aid and assistance, let them get close to Chinese or Vietnamese if they want.Period.

Jul 23, 2018 02:20 AM


from Chicago Jack

This so call free world US has put more people in jail more than any country in world. USA is legally corrupted and jail are run by private company, the more people they put in jail the more money they make. And tax payers end up paying for it. Police brutality is out of control, when they shoot they always shoot to kill and most of the time it minorities that got kill. Not perfect.

Aug 05, 2018 01:21 PM

View all comments.





More Listening Options

View Full Site