Vietnamese Prison Refuses to Mail Jailed Activist’s Appeal Request

Email story
Comment on this story
Print story
Dissident blogger Phan Kim Khanh is shown in an undated photo.
Dissident blogger Phan Kim Khanh is shown in an undated photo.

Prison authorities in Vietnam are refusing to send letters requesting a sentence appeal for democracy advocate and blogger Phan Kim Khanh, who is serving a six-year jail sentence for “spreading propaganda against the state.”

Speaking on Monday to RFA’s Vietnamese service by telephone, his sister Phan Thi Tran said her brother had attempted to send a letter to the court in the northern city of Thai Nguyen shortly after Tet (Lunar New Year, Feb. 5). The letter was a request for an update on an appeal he had attempted to file earlier.

An RFA story in February quoted Phan’s mother as saying he had sent an appeal to the court but got no answer. At the time Phan believed his mail was being sent out, but this appears not to be the case, based on the statement by his sister.

The 25-year-old student was arrested in March 2017 for “abusing rights to freedom and democracy to do harm to the state’s interests and those of organizations and individuals” and was sentenced to six years in jail and four years of probation.

Phan has complained about his treatment in prison.

“Before Tet, they let him call home once a month but they didn’t let him do it last month,” said Phan’s sister.

“When he last called our father went to visit him 2 days later. [My brother] told him that from now on he wouldn’t be allowed to call home and wouldn’t be able to see the family. He also won’t be allowed to get parcels from the family,” she said, adding, “I’m very worried that he might face some danger.”

Ha Huy Son, the lawyer who represented Phan during his Oct. 25 trial, thinks that Phan’s mail should be reaching the court.

“His family said he asked for an appeal but the prison’s authorities didn’t pass his letter to the court. I think they need to look into this,” said Ha.

The lawyer said any effort to take legal action in this case would have to be without him, however.

“According to Vietnamese law, after the trial, as a lawyer I can’t do anything,” he said.

Le Anh Hung

Meanwhile, jailed member of the online Brotherhood of Democracy advocacy group Le Anh Hung is continuing his resistance in prison. According to the Vietnamese Political Prisoner Database, he was arrested in July 2018 and is under pre-trial investigation for “abusing democratic freedoms.” He has refused to be treated as a prisoner prior to sentencing.

“[Prison authorities] told us he violated rules in prison by not wearing a uniform and refusing handcuffs. But my son told me that he hasn’t been tried so they [legally] can’t cuff him,” said Le’s mother, Tran Thi Niem.

Nguyen Vu Binh, an activist and blogger associated with RFA, said that on Le’s mother’s second visit, “he was in a prison uniform and handcuffed, because [prison authorities] said he would not be able to see his family.”

The U.S. has long criticized Vietnam for its human rights record, marked by the suppression of basic freedoms, media censorship, and repression of workers’ rights as well as its worsening record of arresting and imprisoning dissidents, bloggers and religious leaders.

According to New York-based Human Rights Watch, approximately 150 to 200 activists and bloggers are serving prison time in Vietnam simply for exercising their basic rights.

Reported and translated by RFA’s Vietnamese Service. Written in English by Eugene Whong.

Comments (2)

Anonymous Reader

Why do you hate the US so much Mary Pham ? You live in America and you bite the hand that feeds you. And I call this betrayal. You can choose in reside in communist Vietnam instead. By the way please give up your US citizenship before you go.

Apr 04, 2019 03:42 PM

Mary Pham

from usa

RFA is too efficient in news gathering these days for me to keep up... and according to American Human Rights Watch, there will be 200 prisoner updates coming? Anyway, I think Pham Kim Khanh took his appeal case too casually: by laws, he had to send the letter in by Dec. 25, 2018 (60 days after the ruling) - why waited until Feb. 5 to send and Mar. 2 to complaint with RFA... did he / his sister also check the address or enough stamps? As for Brotherhood of Democracy member Le Anh Hung and his problem with handcuffs and uniform: he's better get used to it now in preparation for coming to America. Why didn't his previously immigrated hood brothers tell him that innocent or not, you routinely get cuffed on the LA streets, tased in police cruiser and uniform-robbed on arrival? Remember America is nothing but Laws and Orders!

Apr 03, 2019 06:54 PM





More Listening Options

View Full Site