China's COVID-19 death statistics 'certainly much higher' than reported: WHO

Sources in China say death rates are many times higher than normal since restrictions were lifted.
By Gu Ting and Gao Feng for RFA Mandarin, Cheryl Tung for RFA Cantonese
2023.01.31
China's COVID-19 death statistics 'certainly much higher' than reported: WHO Relatives and neighbors attend the funeral of a woman in a village in Tonglu county, Zhejiang province, China, Jan. 9, 2023.
Credit: Reuters

World Health Organization chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has warned that China's COVID-19 death figures are likely to be "much higher" than its government is saying, a view that is backed up by anecdotal evidence and sources on the ground.

"The moment they relaxed the COVID-19 restrictions, the number of deaths spiked sharply," said Chen Heyang, a person close to the civil affairs department in Wuhan, where the pandemic first emerged three years ago. 

He said his home district of Huangpi had reported around 5,000 deaths in the month since the lockdowns and travel bans of zero-COVID were lifted. "There are around 900,000 people living in Huangpi district, and more than 5,000 deaths in this one month, which is several times the usual [death rate]," he said.

He said the civil affairs bureau has consequently seen a sharp spike in applications for funeral expenses to family members, as well as in applications for the cancellation of household registrations, a necessary piece of paperwork after someone dies.

In mid-January, almost 40,000 COVID-19 weekly deaths were reported to the global health body -- more than half of them in China -- while the true toll "is certainly much higher,” WHO chief Tedros told a committee meeting on Friday.

ENG_CHN_COVIDDeaths_01312023.2.JPG
Patients lie on beds in the emergency department of a hospital in Shanghai, China, Jan. 5, 2023. Credit: Reuters

"As we enter the fourth year of the pandemic, we are certainly in a much better position now than we were a year ago, when the Omicron wave was at its peak, and more than 70,000 deaths were being reported to WHO each week," he said.

But he added the weekly death rate has risen since the start of December, with a spike in deaths following the lifting of the zero-COVID policy in China.

Surging death tolls

In other evidence, a healthcare worker from the eastern province of Jiangsu told Radio Free Asia that the civil affairs computer system in the province had also shown a sharp spike in cancellations of household registrations, called "hukou," implying a sharp rise in the number of deaths recently.

Healthcare professional Wang Ning said the number of cancellations had increased several times over since the lifting of COVID-19 restrictions at the beginning of December.

"For example, in this city, 100 people used to die in a month, but now it is basically between 300 and 500 people," Wang said, citing civil affairs bureau officials personally known to her.

A resident of Wuhan who gave only the surname Zhang for fear of reprisals said most cases and deaths are no longer being reported.

"We can see white chrysanthemums [for mourning] all over the place on the streets right now," Zhang said. "The pandemic worsened as soon as the government opened everything up."

ENG_CHN_COVIDDeaths_01312023.3.JPG
Medical workers attend to COVID-19 patients in an intensive care unit converted from a conference room, at a hospital in Cangzhou, Hebei province, China Jan. 11, 2023. Credit: China Daily via Reuters

His claim was backed up by the New York-based Human Rights Watch, which said in a recent statement that "the authorities suppressed COVID death and infection numbers by preventing hospitals and families from registering Covid as a cause of death."

Repeated calls to the Wuhan municipal, Huangpi district and Jiang'an district civil affairs bureaus rang unanswered during office hours late last week.

An official who answered the phone at the civil affairs bureau in Wuhan's Qiaokou district declined to comment on an increase in household registrations or funeral expense claims.

Lunar New Year wave?

A U.K.-based research firm recently predicted that the current COVID-19 wave could mean as many as 36,000 deaths a day over the Lunar New Year holiday period, as millions of people travel to their ancestral homes to spend time with loved ones.

Beijing says it has been fully "transparent" about its COVID-19 reporting, amid criticism on social media over the government’s reporting of the outbreak and widespread anecdotal evidence that funeral homes are working round the clock to keep pace with a huge rise in demand for cremations.

ENG_CHN_COVIDDeaths_01312023.4.jpg
Passengers traveling during the Lunar New Year arrive at Hankou railway station in Wuhan, in China's central Hubei province, Friday, Jan. 27, 2023. Credit: AFP

In a related development, U.S.-based Chinese student Han Yutao said the ministry of education has said it will end recognition for overseas degrees and diplomas obtained through distance-learning.

The new requirement could force Chinese students to rush back to overseas campuses or risk being left with an unrecognized qualification, Han said.

"They may have chosen to take courses online because they didn't want to leave their homes, and expecting them to suddenly live independently [overseas] is a tough ask," Han said. "But if they don't leave, they will have spent that money for nothing."

He said the winter semester in the United States has been under way for more than a month, with scant accommodation available for late arrivals.

Chinese-Australian Wu Lebao said Beijing is keen to push the narrative that the pandemic is over.

"The propaganda is that the fight has been won, and the pandemic is over," Wu told Radio Free Asia on Tuesday. "All traces of zero-COVID must be erased ... which is a total politicization."

Translated by Luisetta Mudie. Edited by Malcolm Foster.

POST A COMMENT

Add your comment by filling out the form below in plain text. Comments are approved by a moderator and can be edited in accordance with RFAs Terms of Use. Comments will not appear in real time. RFA is not responsible for the content of the postings. Please, be respectful of others' point of view and stick to the facts.

COMMENTS

Kirk Norring
Feb 01, 2023 07:05 AM

It is still under reporting the truth. I have multiple sources including Chinese people living here who can no longer reach any of their family or friends in China. They all say the same thing that I have been hearing.
The daily death toll in China has grown to 30 million people in China.
There are more than 33,000 hospitals in China. They are all full of patients and patients are being told to stay at home. The funeral homes are likely the same number as the hospitals if not more.
How many funeral homes is in your city compared to the number of hospitals?
So say it is 3 funeral homes per hospital and you have a hundred thousand funeral homes.
According to satellite data, the funeral homes are packed with hearses. Time magazine did a news piece on this.
In some cases the funeral homes build extra parking lots to hold the extra hearses.
How many people can be cremated in a day if you load the crematoriums full with 3 bodies burning at a time?

Do the math. It shouldn't be that hard to do.

If the death toll is 30 million a day then China has only weeks before there are no more people left given their population has fallen to under 800 million based on cell phone usage inside of the country.

It is important that you get that data correct here because it isn't just the people that are dying. It is also their military.

China is releasing massive amounts of methane into the atmosphere according to Copernicus which are satellites that can monitor gases in our atmosphere. There is also a high volume of Sulfur Dioxide which is given off when you burn organic matter such as human bodies.

If China's military falls low enough then the US army can just walk into China and turn the methane off at the source.
Methane is a very strong greenhouse gas and if we don't stop it then the Arctic will go ice free in 2024 according to Paul Beckwith, a Climate Scientist often seen reporting to world governments at all of the UN Climate Talks.
Report the news accurately. Our lives depend on it.

[This comment has been edited by RFA Editorial staff per our Terms of Use]