Hague Tribunal Demands Evidence of China’s Sea Claims

By Joshua Lipes
Email story
Comment on this story
Share story
Print story
  • Print
  • Share
  • Comment
  • Email
A Chinese Coast Guard ship (R) uses a water cannon to attack a Vietnamese Fisheries Surveillance boat near the site of a Chinese oil rig in the South China Sea, June 2, 2014.
A Chinese Coast Guard ship (R) uses a water cannon to attack a Vietnamese Fisheries Surveillance boat near the site of a Chinese oil rig in the South China Sea, June 2, 2014.

An international tribunal has asked China to submit evidence defending its territorial claims in the South China Sea within six months, but Beijing shrugged off the request Wednesday, saying it does not recognize the case brought by rival claimant the Philippines.

The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA), the Hague-based inter-governmental body which hears international disputes, issued a statement Tuesday saying it has given China until Dec. 15 to submit its arguments against a complaint by the Philippines, which questioned the legality of China’s so-called “nine-dash line,” encompassing virtually the entire South China Sea.

The Philippines had on March 30 filed a 4,000-page memorial with the PCA detailing its case and seeking to clarify territorial rights in the South China Sea, arguing that Beijing’s claim to most of the South China Sea has no legal basis.

“[T]he Arbitral Tribunal fixes 15 December 2014 as the date for China to submit its Counter-Memorial responding to the Philippines’ Memorial,” the PCA statement said.

Further proceedings, including the need for any further written submissions or hearings, will be determined after “seeking the views” of the involved parties, it said.

“The Arbitral Tribunal has been mindful of its obligation … to determine its own procedure while ‘assuring to each party a full opportunity to be heard and to present its case’.”

Beijing said Wednesday that it had “noted the relevant report,” but said it had no plans to respond.

“China does not accept nor participate in the arbitration case filed by the Philippines,” Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei said during a press briefing.

“This position remains unchanged.”

Rival claims

China rejects rival claims from Vietnam, the Philippines, Taiwan, Malaysia, and Brunei.

Vietnam also is gathering evidence for a legal suit challenging China’s claim to waters off the Vietnamese coast and is considering the best time to file it, Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung told Bloomberg news in an interview last week.

“We are prepared and ready for legal action,” Dung said. “We are considering the most appropriate timing to take this measure.”

The Southeast Asian states have been pushing Beijing to agree to a code of conduct for about a decade to avoid conflicts in the South China Sea.

On May 21, the PCA received a “Note Verbale” from China in which it reiterated its position that “it does not accept the arbitration initiated by the Philippines” and that the Note Verbale “shall not be regarded as China’s acceptance of or participation in the proceedings.”

On Wednesday, Manila pressed for China to join the arbitration process.

“Arbitration is a peaceful, open and friendly resolution mechanism that offers a durable solution to the disputes,” Agence France-Presse quoted Department of Foreign Affairs spokesman Charles Jose telling reporters in Manila.

Ongoing tensions

China’s claims have led to tensions in the South China Sea, most recently with Vietnam after Beijing deployed a giant oil rig in disputed waters off Vietnam’s coast in what Hanoi considers its exclusive economic zone.

Scores of ships from both sides have been involved in a standoff over the rig, with reports of the sinking of a Vietnamese fishing vessel last week.

Frustration over China’s deployment of the oil rig led to demonstrations by thousands of Vietnamese last month, which Hanoi initially allowed in a rare move widely seen as a way to amplify state anger against Beijing.

However, the government backpedaled after protests turned bloody, with riots targeting Chinese business interests. Beijing says four Chinese citizens were killed in the unrest.

Comments (13)
  • Print
  • Share
  • Email


from Bangkok

"International Court is not a JOKE."

What a joke. The international court in the Hague that only prosecutes war criminals that are enemies of NATO. Right, I am sure China would get a fair trial there.

May 11, 2015 12:03 AM


Which Court in the United Nation then is appropriate for this Arbitration as China would like it? Even if CASE falls into that U.N Court chosen by China, still modern court does not validate CLAIMS TO OWN A PARTICULAR SEA WITHOUT VALID AND LEGAL ADMISSIBLE EVIDENCES. Just by saying that HISTORICAL FACTS WERE THE BASIS FOR CHINA CLAIMS is UN ACCEPTABLE. China has to submit admissible evidences supporting their claims.International Court is not a JOKE.

Mar 01, 2015 11:06 PM

Anonymous Reader

Talking about polluting sea ,river and damaging natural flora? How about Vietnam companies controlled by Hanoi cutting down all Cambodia and Laos tries everyday now?The forest are gone because of Vietnam. How about Vietnam companies pupping Cambodia sand everyday causing land slide into sea and river,killing people and destroying their homes?
Don't you think China know about your dirty works on your neighbors ? How about hundred and hundred thousands Vietnamese living in Cambodia big lake polluting water and destroying fish and other species habitats ?

Jun 13, 2014 02:43 PM

Anonymous Reader

QIN happened more than 2200 years ago; it's long gone and has never been back. The Nguyen and the Vietcong are still fresh,starting from the 1800th till today .the Vietcong is still cooking its neighboring countries today........New and fresh Trouble maker Vietcong !

Jun 12, 2014 10:21 AM

Criminal Hans Intimidate Neighbors Again

The QIN State (or CHINA in the West) crushed all her neighbors, murdered the disobedients, burnt books...Today, the very same QIN State starts to Crush, to Heist, to Intimidate Neighbors Again (or in short: C H I N A), and recklessly to damage the natural flora and fauna of the shoals, reefs and islets between the Philippines and Vietnam. This barbarian QIN State pollutes not only the Asian continent but also the sea, the ocean...I wonder how long the world stays standstill before it acts like it did against the NAZI. Btw, NAZI?... Nomen est Omen: ChiNAZI!

Jun 11, 2014 11:57 AM

View all comments.





More Listening Options

View Full Site