Indonesia, Malaysia could see worst haze in five years, report warns

Increased temperature, less rainfall due to El Nino exacerbating the smog problem.
By Subel Rai Bhandari for RFA
2023.06.23
Bangkok
Indonesia, Malaysia could see worst haze in five years, report warns A man flies a kite during a hazy day in Singapore, Sept. 10, 2015.
AP

UPDATES at 12:23 pm EDT, June 23, 2023.

Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore may be hit in coming months with their worst haze crisis in five years due to warming ocean temperatures, a report by a Singapore-based think-tank said.

This year’s heatwave will be a stress test for cooperation between governments and the private sector, according to the Haze Outlook 2023, published Wednesday by the Singapore Institute of International Affairs (SIIA).

It designated a “red” rating for haze, indicating the most severe of the three levels of risk for the first time since the outlook – which analyzes the risk of a severe transboundary haze crisis affecting Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore, and the surrounding region – began five years ago.

However, it did not include the Lower Mekong region of Myanmar, Thailand and Laos, which were hit hard by an extreme haze crisis earlier this year primarily due to wildfires and agricultural waste burning.

“Forest and land fires and the resulting heavy haze pollution across our region have been a recurring problem since 1997,” Simon Tay, the institute’s chairman, said in the report, though the skies “have remained relatively haze-free for the past three years” in Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia.

“This has been due to a combination of effective policy and action by the Indonesian government and larger corporations, and also unusually wet weather, which has made it easier to keep fires in check,” he said. 

“However, there is a real risk in the year ahead that the situation will change, and for the worse. If there is severe dry weather resulting from El Niño, there is a danger that severe transboundary haze will impact us,” Tay said, adding that the region faces “a time of stress testing.”

El Niño, a weather pattern characterized by hot ocean temperatures in the equatorial Pacific, can significantly affect weather patterns worldwide. In Southeast Asia, that would mean warmer, drier weather conditions, which could worsen natural and human-caused fires.

ENG_ENV_HazeCrisis_06232023.1.jpg
Motorists ride on a road as thick haze from forest fires shroud the city in Palangkaraya, Central Borneo, Indonesia, Oct. 27, 2015. Credit: AP

In the last two years the region has seen the cooling influence of La Niña conditions, which ended in March. The U.S. National Ocean and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has predicted a 56% chance that this year’s El Niño will be a strong event, with an 84% chance of at least a moderate event. 

In May, the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) said there was an 80% chance El Niño would appear by October and “this will combine with human-induced climate change to push global temperatures into uncharted territory” with “far-reaching repercussions for health, food security, water management, and the environment.”

The region has already started feeling the effects of a heatwave, with record-breaking heat in parts of Southeast Asia in April and May. Earlier this month, the ASEAN Specialised Meteorological Centre flagged a higher risk of haze in the southern region between June and October.

2015 was region’s worst haze crisis

In 2015, industrial-scale slash-and-burn practices for agricultural purposes, particularly palm oil and pulpwood production, in Indonesia and parts of Malaysia choked a large swath of Southeast Asia with smoke for weeks, causing strained relationships among governments.

The transboundary haze may have caused more than 100,000 deaths, which was 2.7 times higher in 2015 than a decade earlier, according to research in 2016.

Last month, Singapore issued a precautionary advisory to its residents, urging them to acquire an ample supply of face masks and air purifiers.

SIIA said its risk assessment is based on weather (meteorological forecasts), policy (actions taken by governments) and markets (price signals that may drive deforestation, as most forest fires are linked to land clearing for agricultural purposes).

The “red” rating this year is primarily due to the expected heatwave, which increases the chance of forest and peat fires burning out of control and creating haze, SIIA said, adding that a severe dry spell due to a strong El Niño will test the limits of authorities to handle fire prevention efforts and keep the haze under control.

SIIA warned that the agribusiness sector may respond “not only to government regulations but also to markets and prices” as more slash-and-burn techniques may be used to clear land to meet greater demand.

“The price of agricultural commodities has been on a rollercoaster since the start of the pandemic. Prices are starting to stabilize but remain higher than before COVID-19. There is evidence that planting activity is on the rise,” said Khor Yu-Leng, a co-author of the report.

Earlier this month, ministers and senior officials from Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand met in Singapore to discuss transboundary haze pollution, including measures to manage fires and haze in the region.

Ahead of the meeting, environmental group Greenpeace called on ASEAN states to “enact a domestic transboundary haze law in their respective countries where forest fires are known to persist.”

It also asked the countries to “develop a regional legal framework to hold corporate entities accountable for domestic forest fires due to peatland clearance and agricultural residue burning… and compel companies to pay reparations to victims of transboundary haze pollution.”

Edited by Mike Firn.

Updates to recast headline and lead.

POST A COMMENT

Add your comment by filling out the form below in plain text. Comments are approved by a moderator and can be edited in accordance with RFAs Terms of Use. Comments will not appear in real time. RFA is not responsible for the content of the postings. Please, be respectful of others' point of view and stick to the facts.

COMMENTS

Dega people in the Central Highlands in Vietnam
Jun 24, 2023 02:51 PM

Ho Chi Minh and his descendants, including RFA, never could understand the forest management of the Dega people in the Central Highlands of Vietnam that allowed them to exist for thousands of years.
But today, a completely unsustainable form of agriculture is being practiced everywhere, breaking down ecosystems and human societies and causing disastrous climate change. Even the environment of the Central Highlands is now under threat as the sustainable form of forest management of the Dega people has been abandoned. Rapacious Vietnamese timber merchants have cut most of the trees legally and illegally. There are droughts and floods yearly, and land lost fertility. Rivers and streams are polluted, and Dega people are most likely dealing with a drinking water source where a substance introduced into the dampness destroys the existence of fish and other organisms.