Experts Agree With IEP Report: PNPC Dam Collapsed Due to Faulty Construction

2019-05-30
Email story
Comment on this story
Share
Print story
Buffaloes on the roof of a house in the flooded Sanamxay District, Attapeu Province on July 24
Buffaloes on the roof of a house in the flooded Sanamxay District, Attapeu Province on July 24
Photo courtesy of an RFA listener

Several outside experts and the Lao government say a South Korean construction firm is shirking liability for poorly building the hydropower dam that collapsed last year, causing a disaster that has been described as the country’s worst flooding in decades.

The disaster occurred on July 23, 2018 when a saddle dam at the Xe Pian Xe Namnoy (PNPC) hydropower project collapsed following heavy rains, inundating 12 villages and killing at least 40 people in Champassak and Attapeu provinces, leaving many more missing.

Shortly after the release of a report by the International Expert Panel (IEP) that said poor construction methods, with soil used in place of concrete, caused the collapse, SK Engineering & Construction dismissed the IEP’s findings and questioned the scientific basis of its approach.

“Of course the company would not agree with the report, because it doesn’t want to be responsible,” said Ian Baird, a geography professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison in an interview with RFA’s Lao Service.

Baird, who is an expert on Southeast Asia and natural resource management, said he was in agreement with the Lao government’s stance that the cause of the collapse was faulty construction. He added that there is evidence that the developer was trying to cut corners during the dam’s construction.

An official with the Lao Energy and Mines Ministry, speaking to RFA’s Lao Service on the condition of anonymity, said, “The developer has to be responsible according to the concession agreement. [SK Engineering & Construction] should comply with all the terms and conditions of the agreement.”

Other experts also agreed with the report’s findings.

Richard Meehan, a former Stanford University civil engineering professor, said the IEP’s findings were similar to a report he released on the disaster last October.

“They say the same thing. They say that the foundation failed, and the foundation failed because of seepage. So I agreed with that.”

But while experts agree, some in the public were not exactly clear on what the IEP’s report was trying to say.

A survivor of the dam collapse thought the report was using language that was too difficult.

“Those are technical terms. They are not clear and I don’t understand,” the survivor said. “What I know is that the dam collapsed due to substandard construction.”

A source from the Vientiane Capital region also criticized the report for not directly saying which entity should foot the bill for the disaster.

“How come the conclusion of the investigation did not mention at all about who should be responsible for the damages?” he said.

Meanwhile, a member of a South Korean civil society organization said there are still doubts about the accuracy of the report.

“First of all, we want transparency on the investigation by all stake holders,” the activist said.

“We wonder whether the investigation was deep, good and fair enough, and how the local people participated in the process. The report contained no information on this. We still have doubts about the process of the investigation and we want more information on [how it was conducted],” added the South Korean, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

Reported and translated by RFA’s Lao Service. Written in English by Eugene Whong.

Comments (2)
Share

(

It's predictable that the south Korean contruction comapany would deny responsibility further to dam collapse. They've already paid $10,000 as compensation to victims and it's more than enough.Now it's time for the Lao party-state to take action but unfortunately they have no way out. The Lao party-state was hugely paid under the table and besides lives of Lao peasants don't mean much to Lao leaders. Somseuay, somseuay . . .


[This comment has been edited by RFA Editorial staff per our Terms of Use]

Jun 03, 2019 09:53 AM

The Truth

from Vientiane

This is not a Faulty structure THIS IS A SET UP TRAP TO WIOE OUT THIS AREA. Just look at how the Alert Warning Local People in this Disaster Area The DAM was Leaking many days before Accident but NO BODY TELL THE LOCAL PEOPLE UBTIL IS TOO LATE. THEY GAVE LOCAL PEOPLE ONE HOUR TO RELOCATE BUT HOW COULD THEY RELOCATE WHILE WATER IS ALREADY ABOVE THEIR KNEES THEY ARE POOR THEY HAVE NO BOATS NO CAR NOTHING. YOU CAN NOT COVER UP THE TRUTH

Jun 01, 2019 02:26 PM

CH. 1: MANDARIN | CANTONESE

CH. 2: VIETNAMESE | BURMESE | KOREAN

CH. 3: KHMER | LAO | UYGHUR

CH. 4: TIBETAN

More Listening Options

View Full Site