Chinese censors clamp down on public mourning for former premier

Reports emerge that universities are moving to nip student memorials in the bud, 'online or offline.'
By Gigi Lee and Siyan Cheung for RFA Cantonese, Hwang Chun-mei and Gu Ting for RFA Mandarin
2023.10.27
Chinese censors clamp down on public mourning for former premier A man bows in front of the former house of former Chinese Premier Li Keqiang in Dingyuan county, Chuzhou city, in China's eastern Anhui province on Friday, Oct. 27, 2023.
Rebecca Bailey/AFP

"The people's premier." "Rest in peace." "A good premier whose political career shouldn't have ended the way it did."

Chinese people took to social media with candle emojis and condolences to mourn the death of former premier Li Keqiang on Friday – until censors stepped in to ensure that only uniform and formulaic condolences remained for the 68-year-old technocrat, who died of a heart attack in the early hours of Friday morning in Shanghai.

Earlier on Friday, it was still possible to see personal comments from individual users lauding Li's perceived qualities as a national leader, including a widely shared video clip of the late former premier talking about the problems faced by Chinese farmers and descriptions of him as "the people's premier."

But by Friday night, much of the individual content was no longer available, with only state media and official statements turning up in search results for "Li Keqiang" and related keywords.

The majority of condolences on the official state television report on Li's sudden death by heart attack at a Shanghai hotel appeared limited to the "wishing you a good journey," the Chinese equivalent of "rest in peace."

The official government announcement of Li's death on Weibo showed no comments but tens of thousands of likes and reposts, suggesting that comments had been turned off.

Meanwhile, a citizen journalist account on X started posting warnings from the authorities on university campuses across the country not to post anything political online, not to use words to describe Li that were not already approved by state media, and not to leave flowers, hold gatherings or engage in any kind of public mourning, on or offline.

The X account "Mr. Li is not your teacher" posted photos of notices banning any kind of public gathering issued by officials at universities in Shanghai, in the southern province of Hainan and the southwestern province of Guizhou.

News of Li Keqiang’s death quickly topped Weibo’s hot search rankings on Friday. Credit: RFA screenshot
News of Li Keqiang’s death quickly topped Weibo’s hot search rankings on Friday. Credit: RFA screenshot

It also posted photos of yellow and white floral tributes on a street in the eastern city of Hefei, the traditional colors for a Chinese funeral.

"As night falls, more and more flowers are laid under Li Keqiang’s former residence," the account commented.

The reported bans on public mourning for Li come less than a year after students and other young people flocked to take part in the "white paper" protests after three years of grueling COVID lockdowns.

Student union leaders in Hainan University were told to hold an emergency meeting, and not to record the proceedings, and to ban any online or offline mourning activities, including "rallies, demonstrations, floral tributes and other memorial activities."

Ghosts of 1989

Students at Guiyang Aviation Industry Technology College were warned off posting anything online for the next few days, including comments in group chats, blog posts or livestream video. They have also been barred from talking to the media.

"If any harmful speech occurs or material is disseminated, it will be transferred to the judicial authorities for serious handling," the message warned, according to a photo posted by "Mr. Li is not your teacher."

Staff at Shanghai Jiaotong University were ordered to "immediately get in among the students, pay attention to their thoughts and opinions at this time, and resolutely ban any inappropriate remarks, online or offline."

"Pay attention to students' movements over the next couple of days ... and to any gatherings or mourning activities on campus," the notice said.

The evening news broadcast shows an obituary photo of the former Premier Li Keqiang on a giant LED screen in Beijing, Friday, Oct. 27, 2023. Credit: Ng Han Guan/AP
The evening news broadcast shows an obituary photo of the former Premier Li Keqiang on a giant LED screen in Beijing, Friday, Oct. 27, 2023. Credit: Ng Han Guan/AP

Li isn't the first Chinese premier to die suddenly of a heart attack.

In April 1989, thousands flocked onto Tiananmen Square in a mass public outpouring of grief over the sudden death of widely loved premier Hu Yaobang. Those gatherings developed into a weeks-long mass pro-democracy movement ending in a massacre of civilians by the People's Liberation Army.

According to late Communist Party official Bao Tong, who was in government at the time: "The whole nation was plunged into grief. In a commemoration that took its cue from that for [former premier] Zhou Enlai, the students began making their way to Tiananmen Square in silence."

"In 1977, people were ostensibly mourning for Zhou, but in fact were turning out against Mao. In 1989, they were ostensibly mourning for Hu, but things were even more complicated. Not only was Hu a former General Secretary who had presided over the throwing out of thousands of trumped up criminal cases, but he was also a politician who was kicked out for falling foul of [late supreme leader] Deng [Xiaoping]."

An era of 'turmoil'

Similarly, the initial outpouring of public grief for Li Keqiang was more of a reflection of public dissatisfaction with life under ruling Chinese Communist Party leader Xi Jinping than an endorsement of Li's performance as premier, according to current affairs commentator Si Ling.

"A lot of people are trying their best to express their condolences or have discussions about Li Keqiang in various online spaces," Si said. "It's like a [collective] sigh over the current difficulties in today's China, and about pessimism over the country's future."

"Li Keqiang's death has become a symbol, and an excuse for people to vent serious dissatisfaction with the status quo," he said.

Financial commentator Xiang Xiang said China's internet users can tell without being told that keyword searches related to Li's death have been classified as having "major political or social sensitivity" by the Chinese government.

"Any discussion of Li Keqiang's merits or faults is totally prohibited," Xiang said.

Instead, readers are directed by keyword search results to state news agency Xinhua's official obituary and other state media content.

Chinese students link arms in solidarity at dawn on April 22, 1989 in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square after spending the night there in order to be on hand for memorial services for the late purged party chief Hu Yaobang. Credit: Sadayuki Mikami/AP
Chinese students link arms in solidarity at dawn on April 22, 1989 in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square after spending the night there in order to be on hand for memorial services for the late purged party chief Hu Yaobang. Credit: Sadayuki Mikami/AP

Si said the topic is particularly sensitive as it comes after China's defense minister Li Shangfu and foreign minister Qin Gang were removed from their posts in relatively quick succession. Neither had been long in office.

"A series of personnel changes at the highest levels of the Chinese government have reminded people that the current era is one of ... turmoil," he said, adding that comparisons with the death of Hu Yaobang in 1989 are inevitable.

"He also handed over the reins of power and then died shortly after leaving office," Si said. "People started to hold public memorials, which led to the 1989 democracy movement, throwing the Chinese government into turmoil for a long time to come."

"Even though Li Keqiang lacks Hu Yaobang's political pedigree or historic status, the Chinese government would rather kill a thousand by mistake than let one go free."

"Any chance that history might repeat itself will be completely nipped in the bud," Si said.


Translated with additional reporting by Luisetta Mudie.

POST A COMMENT

Add your comment by filling out the form below in plain text. Comments are approved by a moderator and can be edited in accordance with RFAs Terms of Use. Comments will not appear in real time. RFA is not responsible for the content of the postings. Please, be respectful of others' point of view and stick to the facts.