Vietnam deputy defense minister on rare visit to North Korea

Analysts warn that closer ties with North Korea may harm Vietnam’s improving relations with the US and South Korea.
By RFA Staff
2024.09.19
Vietnam deputy defense minister on rare visit to North Korea Bilateral talks between Vietnam’s deputy defense minister Hoang Xuan Chien and North Korea’s deputy defense minister Kim Min Sop in Pyongyang, Sept. 18, 2024.
Vietnam Ministry of National Defense

A Vietnam defense ministry delegation is in North Korea on a rare visit to boost cooperation, the ministry has announced on its website

The visit has raised eyebrows as it takes place just days after North Korea revealed the first images of centrifuges used for enriching uranium at a production base for weapons-grade nuclear material.

North Korea is also under U.N. Security Council sanctions for its nuclear weapons and missile programs.

On Thursday, Vietnam's deputy defense minister, Senior Lt. Gen. Hoang Xuan Chien, held a bilateral meeting with his North Korean counterpart, Lt. Gen. Kim Min Sop.

The two sides “exchanged views on the current situation in the world and the region, as well as in both countries,” the Vietnamese ministry said, adding that they shared information about their countries’ defense policies. 

“Defense cooperation is one of the important aspects of the bilateral relations,” the ministry said.

The officials agreed that Vietnam and North Korea would continue exchanges on multiple levels and strengthen cooperation in military medicine, border defense, defense industry, military technology and information sharing.

‘Misleading signals’

Chien invited Kim to visit Vietnam in December for the 80th anniversary celebrations of the Vietnam People’s Army and its second International Defense Expo from Dec. 19-22.

International weapons suppliers showcase their products at the expo, which is seen as an attempt by Hanoi to diversify its sources of imported arms.

North Korea’s state-run Korean Central News Agency, or KCNA, had not reported on Chien’s visit at time of publication.

VISIT.jpg
Vietnam’s deputy defense minister Hoang Xuan Chien visits a facility of the North Korean special forces, Sept. 18, 2024. (Vietnam Ministry of National Defense)

Analysts said the visit carried risks for Vietnam.

“To be honest, I am quite puzzled by the move,” said a Vietnamese analyst who wished to remain anonymous as he is not authorized to speak to foreign media.

“This trip can send very misleading signals about Vietnam’s intention, especially as defense minister Phan Van Giang has just visited the United States,” he said.

The new general secretary of the Vietnamese Communist Party, To Lam, is expected to address the U.N. General Assembly in New York later this week.

“Vietnam wants to be friends with everyone but as a responsible member of the international community, it shouldn’t be seen as contradicting U.N. sanctions in any way,” the analyst warned.

Nguyen The Phuong, a defense analyst at the University of New South Wales in Australia, said Vietnam was unlikely to  procure weapons from North Korea.

“Beside the quality problem, violating U.N.'s sanctions regarding North Korea would be disastrous,” he said.


RELATED STORIES

Vietnam defense minister Phan Van Giang visits US to boost ties

North Korea unveils uranium enrichment facility for the first time

Xi’s latest message to North Korea’s Kim hints at cooling ties


For years China has been North Korea’s sole main ally but it has been boosting its foreign friendships in recent months. 

North Korean leader Kim Jong Un welcomed Russian President Vladimir Putin on a visit in June when they announced a partnership treaty, agreeing to offer each other military assistance “without delay.” 

The U.S. says North Korea has provided Russia with large amounts of weapons for the war in Ukraine, which both North Korea and Russia deny.

Long history

Vietnam and the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, or DPRK – as North Korea is officially known – have a long history of friendship and cooperation. In 2025, they will celebrate the 75th anniversary of diplomatic ties.

North Korea was an ally of the then North Vietnam during the Vietnam War and provided substantial economic and military assistance, including weapons and ammunition. 

North Korea reportedly transferred to Vietnam a number of midget submarines and missiles during the 1990s.

Vietnam-North Korea ties, however, have weakened in recent years as Hanoi and Seoul strengthened their cooperation, especially in investment and business.

South Korea has become one of Vietnam’s most important partners and in 2022 they elevated their relationship to a comprehensive strategic partnership, the highest tier of bilateral cooperation.

“Vietnam should bear in mind the risk of jeopardizing the relations with Seoul,” the Hanoi-based analyst said. 

Some Korean analysts, such as Kim Young-sun, a former secretary general of the ASEAN-Korea Center, said that defense cooperation requires the highest levels of trust between countries and South Korea should consider carefully any plan to transfer arms to Vietnam. 

Edited by Mike Firn.

POST A COMMENT

Add your comment by filling out the form below in plain text. Comments are approved by a moderator and can be edited in accordance with RFAs Terms of Use. Comments will not appear in real time. RFA is not responsible for the content of the postings. Please, be respectful of others' point of view and stick to the facts.

COMMENTS

Dega people Central Highlands of Vietnam
Sep 19, 2024 01:49 PM

Vietnam tries to be friendly with everyone with the aim of getting an atomic bomb, but not with the Dega people in the Central Highlands.
The different forms of atomic already used were when the colonialist Vietnamese settlers, in their process to gain land in every corner where Dega people lived with alcohol producers to attack deep down in the sterm brain, and as a result, Dega people disappeared on their ancestral land.
Of course, even though they will have atomic bombs, they do not dare to bomb America, China, or Russia.
It is just only for fun to treat everyone around Southeast Asia countries and steal their resources.

Anonymous
Sep 19, 2024 08:25 PM

..They (vietnam) just want to take advantages from you (US) and the world, they take your money and ... hit back you! Don't trust them!